Saturday, 29 August 2009

Do you know who’s who in your Hospital?

Unless you’re a frequent flyer at your hospital you’ve probably got no idea who’s who when it comes to determining who’s a doctor and who’s a nurse. Even I have trouble at times and I’m a nurse.

Think about it, the uniforms worn by health care professionals range from casually to smartly dressed doctors to a plethora of different uniforms amongst permanent, casual and agency nurses; all of whom have nonexistent to very little clear visible means of identification.

Of course, we all have identification cards that hang down near our navels, but so does everyone else, and, if you’re anything like me you need to get up close and personal to work out who the hell you’re talking to.

Just in case you’re wondering, I always introduce myself to the patients I care for and inform them what my role is first time around; which is normally followed by the words, “Care for a cuppa?” But! Occasionally I’ve had to say to patients, whilst the doctor looked on slightly embarrassed, “I’m not your doctor, I’m your nurse.”

This identification crisis wasn’t a problem in the 1970’s when nurses wore identical uniforms and doctors wore white coats; with patients knowing full well, who was who in the pecking order. While I’m on that, I can also remember being threatened to be hang, drawn and quartered by the St Vincent’s Hospital management team if ever I was caught wearing my nurses uniform out on the streets! How things have changed!

In the days when you could tell who was who

Yes, healthcare has come a long way in Australia since then but we seem to have lost the plot in regards to letting patients and visitors know who’s who in the hospital.

The current identification crisis in hospitals that has caused so much confusion and stress amongst patients, family members and visitors was recently brought up in the Garling Report. You may remember that I referred to this report sometime ago in my article titled, “Mixed-sex hospital wards”.

Commissioner Peter Garling makes a recommendation in his 2008 “Final Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Acute Care Services in New South Wales (NSW) Public Hospitals” to remedy this crisis but it appears to have fallen on deaf ears.

It’s now almost twelve months since he outlined in recommendation 62 (Volume 2, Chapter 15, page 564 onwards © State of NSW through the Attorney General’s Department of NSW) that:

Within 12 months, NSW Health implement a state-wide policy ensuring uniforms or vests are worn by each health professional, identifying in large print the role of the health professional. The state-wide policy should:

(a) Designate a colour to each professional role and ensure that the colour is consistently adopted;

(b) Include a requirement for posters to be prominently displayed throughout NSW Health facilities providing a chart to indicate which uniform or colour is assigned to which profession; and

(c) NSW Health amend existing policy or develop additional policy to require the wearing of name badges (or similar, but not cards on lanyards) by each type of health professional, bearing in large print the person’s name and title or role.


and as far as I can see nothing has been done to improve the system he deemed inadequate.

So, where to from here? Do we go back to the good old days, or, considering the poor financial state of the Health System, act on the recommendations when times get better?

To delay it any further, is to only confuse and stress the ones we have been empowered to care for even more; an intolerable situation.

(1) Has your hospital got its act together? (2) Do you know who’s who in your hospital? (3) Please let me know your thoughts on this.

To be continued…

10 comments - care to make one?:

Bob Johnson 30/08/09 6:02 AM  

Very interesting Peter,and good points. I don't frequent the Hospital at all, had a EKG a few years back, I did notice all types of colors though, green yellow and pink, I could tell the doctors a mile away, always had a white coat on, didn't notice anyone else with a white coat, a lot of white pull over type smocks for techs I was involved with.

Anna 31/08/09 9:24 AM  

Peter I am not frequent anymore, but you know these days uniforms are confusing, some of them would probably be better worn in the kitchen, lol. Kidding aside, where I grew up in Europe, the hospitals, and clinics were much more groomed and cleaner [well 25 + years ago], and they smelled truly like doctor's office. Now you walk in to hospital here in Canada, you don't know if you are in the government office or hospital, so run down. Most of all I tend to draw my sleeves over my hands so I don't have to touch anything. If comes to uniforms to distinguish between nurses and doctors, I cannot tell any more.

BTW Peter, did you have to wear that thing on your head back then?

Hopefully I said what you needed to hear, lol.

Anna :)

Peter 31/08/09 6:12 PM  

Hi Bob! Scrubs seem to be the "in thing" at the moment in my neck of the woods. The three colours used are blue, red and green.

The ones wearing blue I call the worker bees (nurses), the ones in red, the bishops! (nurse bosses) with the senior ED doctors wearing green.

I love to see them have in large print, "Nurse" or "Doctor" on them, which I think would make things a lot easier for patients.

The one problem I've seen with them, is that when the air-conditioning gets too cold, some start throwing on jumpers or coats!

Thank you for your input!

Take Care,
Peter

Peter 31/08/09 6:14 PM  

Hi Anna! I believe the scrubs that are in fashion in most ED's originated from the operating room. I tend to think they should have left them there and gone for something more hardy! But that's only my opinion mind you!

Anna, if I can get though a hospital door without touching the handle, all the better for me!

As for those cute nursing caps, this Mr. Sister didn't have to wear one, thank heavens!

Great comment Anna, you've done well!

Take Care,
Peter

Dorothy 1/09/09 11:17 AM  

Great post and yes I've spent a lot of time in hospitals because of my cancer..However, your right and the uniforms etc have made me crazy you never know who anyone is and half of the times they don't wear name tags.

Glad I visited..

Dorothy from grammology
grammology.com

Max Coutinho 2/09/09 1:04 AM  

Hey Peter,

You have brought up a very pertinent issue: indeed, nowadays it is very hard to identify the hospital staff (first, because nurses do not wear a nurse uniform any longer; and second because even some doctors do not wear the white coats any longer...they all wear that blue/greenish surgeon outfit)...so, I get a bit confused as well (in the rare times I visit a hospital).

Aww, you are so nice, Pete! I would love to be treated by a nurse like you: I bet patients get more at ease after you introduce yourself.

I totally agree with Garling's report, and in my opinion his suggestions should be followed and implemented (for obviously he is concerned with the patients - one is already sick, then adding to the situation the confusion of not knowing who is who...how stressing).

"1) Has your hospital got its act together?" - no. Like I said, it confuses me.

"(2) Do you know who’s who in your hospital?" - again, no. I remember one time going to the hospital visiting my brother (he had broken his leg while playing football) and I called nurse to a doctor lol *nodding*...it was embarrassing, but again they all wear the same garments *shrugging*.

Have a great week!

Cheers

Peter 3/09/09 10:52 PM  

Hi Dorothy and a big thank you for your comment! It's one thing to work on the floor of a hospital but to be a patient, as you have been unfortunately, you obviously know what it's like to run into so many uniforms that can confuse. I'm sorry that it drove you crazy and if I could have made it any easier for you, I would have. Please take care and all the best with your health - Peter

Peter 4/09/09 1:09 AM  

Hi Max! It would be my pleasure to look after you if ever you needed a nurse! Do they have male nurses in Portugal? and if so, is it a popular choice for men over there?

Take Care,
Peter

Max Coutinho 5/09/09 1:16 AM  

Hi Peter!

"It would be my pleasure to look after you if ever you needed a nurse!"

Thank you so much, mate :D!

"Do they have male nurses in Portugal? and if so, is it a popular choice for men over there?"

Yes, we have male nurses in Portugal. I suppose it is a popular choice; for now I see as much male nurses as females (a few years ago, we had more female nurses than male, but things have changed).
My mother says that male nurses are better than female nurses (from her own experience). I have been treated once by a male nurse, and he was quite nice (he'd explain me things as I asked him, I was impressed; cause female nurses here have no patience at all).

Have a blessed weekend, my friend!

Cheers

Peter 6/09/09 1:35 AM  

Hi Max! It's a well known fact that male nurses try harder to please. On top of that they have a great bed side manner about them as well!

Take Care,
Peter

Post a Comment


WELCOME TO ALL THAT COME HERE

Hi! Thank you for visiting and I hope you enjoyed your visit. Comments are welcomed and would be greatly appreciated, as I would really like to hear what you have to say!

Wishing you and your family a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

Take Care,
Peter McCartney
Sydney Australia

Popular Posts


MyBlogLog Readers

Blogcatalog Readers

Recent Comments

  © Free Blogger Templates Spain by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008 / Header Image Credit - Athaydesbr

Back to TOP