Mixed-Sex Hospital Wards
On Tuesday, 24 March 2009 it was announced here in my home state of New South Wales (NSW), Sydney Australia, that our ruling Australian Labour Party (ALP) Government, will abolish mixed-sex hospital wards and rooms over the next four years at the cost of $12 million. This is in response to a 10 month Garling inquiry into public hospitals in 2008 with the final report being published back on the 27th November 2008.
As Commissioner of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Acute Care Services in NSW Public Hospitals, Mr Peter Garling S.C. gives his recommendation 124 in volume 3 [page 992, chapter 28 (28.37 to 28.42) relates] of his report which the government is now implementing. His directive is:
”The policy which authorises, and the practice which gives effect to, using inpatient wards (except Intensive Care Units, High Dependency Units and Emergency Departments) to house both men and women in the same room, or separate ward space ought to cease forthwith.”
As a result the New South Wales Health Minister, John Della Bosca, made the following comment to the media on the 24th of this month in regards to his parties implementation of this recommendation:
As Commissioner of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Acute Care Services in NSW Public Hospitals, Mr Peter Garling S.C. gives his recommendation 124 in volume 3 [page 992, chapter 28 (28.37 to 28.42) relates] of his report which the government is now implementing. His directive is:
”The policy which authorises, and the practice which gives effect to, using inpatient wards (except Intensive Care Units, High Dependency Units and Emergency Departments) to house both men and women in the same room, or separate ward space ought to cease forthwith.”
As a result the New South Wales Health Minister, John Della Bosca, made the following comment to the media on the 24th of this month in regards to his parties implementation of this recommendation:
"Gender-based rooms will enhance a patient's experience by providing greater personal privacy, improving their dignity and encouraging more open and improved communications between patients and health care professionals."
The NSW State Premier, Nathan Rees, backed his minister by adding “I think that’s a good thing” with the opposition health spokeswoman Jillian Skinner welcoming the government's decision.
I couldn’t agree more with this decision and with that I hope to see an end to mixed-sex wards forever.
Now, I’ve been reading a few comments left on major news web sites here and overseas about this issue. The majority are in favour of abolishing it, whilst the small minority advocate keeping mixed-sex wards. One commentator stated, “Better a mixed ward than no bed…”. I must admit he has a point and will beds go empty and waiting lists become even longer as a result of this change.
With ever-tightening Hospital budgets and access block (the prolonged wait for an inpatient hospital bed after emergency department treatment) being a major concern, some hospitals may struggle to implement the plan. We will just have to wait and see if the current NSW Labour Government will succeed, bearing in mind the small budget allocation.
Going on my personal remarks above you know where I stand. Now it’s over to you! Let me know what you think by way of comment and vote (vote over: 8 to 4 in favour of abolishing mixed-sex wards); are mixed-sex hospital wards and rooms a good thing or a bad thing? Have you ever been in one and what were your experiences?
References and Links:
1. Final Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Acute Care Services in NSW Public Hospitals.
2. ”Caring Together: Gender-based rooms for hospital patients” NSW Government Department of Health
3. ”Single-sex wards return to NSW” ABC News
4.”Single-sex wards a good thing: Rees” The Sydney Morning Herald
With ever-tightening Hospital budgets and access block (the prolonged wait for an inpatient hospital bed after emergency department treatment) being a major concern, some hospitals may struggle to implement the plan. We will just have to wait and see if the current NSW Labour Government will succeed, bearing in mind the small budget allocation.
Going on my personal remarks above you know where I stand. Now it’s over to you! Let me know what you think by way of comment and vote (vote over: 8 to 4 in favour of abolishing mixed-sex wards); are mixed-sex hospital wards and rooms a good thing or a bad thing? Have you ever been in one and what were your experiences?
References and Links:
1. Final Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Acute Care Services in NSW Public Hospitals.
2. ”Caring Together: Gender-based rooms for hospital patients” NSW Government Department of Health
3. ”Single-sex wards return to NSW” ABC News
4.”Single-sex wards a good thing: Rees” The Sydney Morning Herald
To be continued…















